A bad dream? Why Montreal will miss P.K. Subban so badly

The Journal de Montréal tabloid's Thursday front page carries the stark headline «BYE BYE P.K. » and 14 pages inside cover every minute detail of a hockey trade that is already being compared to the infamous slammed-door departure of Canadiens superstar goalie Patrick Roy 20 years ago.

Operatic is one way to describe the reaction in Montreal – and not only among hockey fans – to the news that adopted son P.K. Subban has been traded to the Nashville Predators.

• READ MORE: Canadiens trade P.K. Subban to Predators for Shea Weber

The star Montreal Canadiens defenseman was loved by so many not only for his on-ice skills and showboating but for his presence in the city as a bon vivant, sharp dresser, warm and friendly demeanor, and community involvement.

The Toronto-born Mr. Subban arrived as a rookie in 2010 and soon won over a big fan contingent with his style and finesse on the ice. But he also won the hearts of many for his ability to connect with people, his infectious laugh and fun-loving nature.

Kids adored him.

"Their eyes light up" when they meet him, said Élise Béliveau, the widow of Habs great Jean Béliveau, who became one of Mr. Subban's biggest fans.

Mr. Subban was no slouch on the philanthropic front. Last year, he pledged $10-million over 7 years to the Montreal Children's Hospital, considered to be the biggest donation by a sports figure in Canadian history.

• READ MORE: P.K. Subban pledges $10 million to Montreal Children’s Hospital

Adding to his popularity were the efforts he put into speaking French.

In 2013 he won the Norris Trophy for best defenseman in the NHL.

But his relationship with his teammates and management was a rocky one. Many players resented his boastfulness; some said he lacked team spirit and on occasion showed poor judgment on the ice.

"He clearly wasn't someone who conformed – he strayed from the beaten path – but he had a magnificent connection with the people of Montreal and that's why we loved him," Montreal Mayor Denis Coderre said.

Mr. Subban was "the only player who gave the Canadiens a soul," said one angry tweeter.