Bond funds were the big winner in a gangbuster November for exchange-traded funds.
What’s happening here is that a lot of smart investors are jumping on an opportunity to get into a beaten down asset ahead of a bond rally that can legitimately be described as inevitable. The only question is on the timing.
Inflows of money into bond ETFs totalled $2.3-billion last month, numbers from National Bank Financial show. Equity funds took in $1.6-billion, a bit less than half going into Canadian equity funds and the rest more or less evenly split between U.S. and international funds.
There’s opportunity to buy stocks low, too. While the Canadian stock market has recovered to levels not far off the start of the year, both the S&P 500 and Nasdaq are still down by double-digit amounts. Based on some good days recently for the U.S. market, there’s been some chatter that this year’s bear market in stocks is over. But the risk of a recession must be considered, too. The year ahead may not be a stellar one for corporate profits.
Bonds shocked investors this year with brutal losses that can be summed up in the 10.2 per cent decline in the FTSE Canada Universe Bond Index for the first 11 months of the year. That’s a total return number - it includes bond price changes and interest.
Bonds are starting to recover, though. In November alone, the index jumped 2.8 per cent on sentiment that the Bank of Canada is just about done increasing rates to fight inflation. A resurgence of inflation would massacre bonds, but there’s a growing sense that we have turned the corner in containing the rising cost of living.
Three of the five most popular ETFs in November were aggregate bond funds: the Vanguard Canadian Aggregate Bond Index ETF (VAB-T), the Horizons Cdn Select Universe Bond ETF (HBB-T) and the BMO Aggregate Bond Index ETF (ZAG-T). These funds give you exposure to government and corporate bonds, and to bonds maturing in the short, medium and long term. They’re an ideal way to play a bond market rebound – you’re essentially buying the entire bond market in one cheap package and waiting for lower interest rates to do their work.
To quickly review bond market mechanics, rising rates depress the price of bonds and falling rates increase bond prices. In the bond market, they’re already starting to price in the rate increases ahead. Smart investors are taking note.
-- Rob Carrick, personal finance columnist
Also see:
After a terrible year for U.S. bonds, the outlook Is better
Eleven new ETFs launch on TSX as inflows to Canadian funds highest since March
This is the Globe Investor newsletter, published three times each week. If someone has forwarded this e-mail newsletter to you or you’re reading this on the web, you can sign up for the newsletter and others on our newsletter signup page.
Stocks to ponder
Dollarama Inc. (DOL-T) The discount retailer has thrived in an environment of soaring inflation and rising borrowing costs. But now, its investors could face a challenging environment of a decidedly different sort: Many economists believe that inflation has crested. So much for Dollarama’s appeal to stressed consumers stretching their dollars. Where does the stock go from here? David Berman shares some thoughts.
The Rundown
The 250 largest stocks on the TSX, rated by The Globe
Norman Rothery is back with a new Megastar ranking of Canada’s largest publicly traded companies. It provides key investing data on 250 major stocks. Each one is analyzed and awarded two star ratings – one for its appeal to value investors and the other for its allure to momentum investors. He then combines value and momentum to select 20 Megastar stocks for the best of both worlds. Historically, it’s a strategy that has resulted in big-time outperformance against the Canadian benchmark.
Why this portfolio manager is buying stock in an auctioneer and selling a grocer
While some investors are on the sidelines, waiting for more market fallout from a widely anticipated economic slowdown heading into next year, money manager Rob Spafford is actively buying. “You have to be investing ahead of that slowdown because, by the time we’re actually in a recession, the markets are going to be well on their way to recovery,” says the vice-president and portfolio manager at Cidel Asset Management in Toronto. “Stock valuations are low, and we think there are some opportunities in this environment,” adds Mr. Spafford, who helps oversee about $2.7-billion in Canadian equities. The Globe and Mail recently spoke to Mr. Spafford about what he’s been buying and selling.
The odds of your mutual fund consistently beating the market? Slim to none
Beating the market is hard. Not even the pros can do it with any kind of consistency, despite what the investment fund industry would have you believe. Out of more than 650 Canadian actively managed equity mutual funds, how many of them were able to maintain superior returns over the last five years? Exactly zero. Tim Shufelt reports.
Oil or clean energy? Investing in both can offset risk
Would you rather bet on oil rigs or solar panels? Investors tend to be fervently committed to one sector or the other, often for reasons of ideology more than economics. In fact, it makes a lot of sense to hold both. The two battling industries can offset each other’s risks, says Ian McGugan.
Investors on alert for policy error after cheering slower rate hikes
Central banks are starting to slow aggressive rate rises but are far from done even as recession looms, leaving investors alert to risks that prolonged tightening could hurt the economy more than necessary.
Also see: U.S. stock rally faces gauntlet of CPI data, Fed meeting
Fund managers still see no reason to be bullish on copper
Copper’s future in the energy transition may be bright but it’s the problematic here and now that is weighing on fund managers’ minds. As veteran metals reporter Andy Home reports, bulls remain conspicuous by their absence, waiting to see how Doctor Copper prices the confusing combination of Western recession and tentative recovery in China.
Others (for subscribers)
The most oversold and overbought stocks on the TSX
Monday’s analyst upgrades and downgrades
Monday’s Insider Report: Company leaders are trading these four dividend stocks
Globe Advisor
Five key investment themes to consider for 2023
Are you a financial advisor? Register for Globe Advisor (www.globeadvisor.com) for free daily and weekly newsletters, in-depth industry coverage and analysis, and access to ProStation - a powerful tool to help you manage your clients’’ portfolios.
Ask Globe Investor
Question: I want to invest in a guaranteed investment certificate, but I noticed something odd when shopping for rates at my discount broker. The yields offered on one- to three-year GICs are all more than 5 per cent, but four- and five-year GICs pay less than 5 per cent. Shouldn’t I be getting paid more, not less, to lock my money up for a longer time period?
Answer: Normally, that would be the case. Because investing your capital for a longer term carries more risk, you would typically earn a premium for doing so. Graphically speaking, if you were to plot the yields of one- to five-year GICs, the line would slope gradually up and to the right.
But these are not normal times. Now, the line slopes downward, meaning the lowest yields are paid for longer maturity periods. This is what’s known as an inverted yield curve, and it’s especially pronounced in the bond market right now.
As of Friday, Government of Canada bonds maturing in one year were yielding 4.39 per cent. Three-year bonds were yielding 3.56 per cent, and five-year bonds just 3.05 per cent.
An inverted yield curve is often said to signal an economic slowdown. Indeed, this is precisely what the Bank of Canada has been trying to engineer by hiking its short-term policy interest rate – including a half-point increase this week – in an attempt to get inflation back under control.
What the bond and GIC markets are predicting, essentially, is that interest rates will fall as the economy slows and the central bank wrestles inflation to the ground. That’s why you’re getting a lower, not higher, yield if you lock in a GIC for four or five years compared with a one- to three-year GIC.
Does this mean four- and five-year GICs are a bad deal? Not necessarily. If interest rates do start to fall, as expected, locking in now at a rate of, say, 4.8 per cent might turn out to be a smart move. You’ll continue to collect 4.8 per cent for many years even as yields on new GICs fall. There are no guarantees that events will play out exactly as expected, however.
To control your risk, one of the best strategies is to build a ladder of GICs. For example, you could invest equal amounts of your money in GICs with maturities ranging from one to five years. When the one-year GIC matures, roll the proceeds into a new five-year GIC, and so on. By staggering your maturities, you’ll avoid having all of your GICs coming due at the same time, possibly when interest rates are very low.
--John Heinzl (E-mail your questions to jheinzl@globeandmail.com)
What’s up in the days ahead
The Contra Guys look at the investment case for Canadian small-cap Quarterhill. Plus, former bond fund manager Tom Czitron provides his outlook for what the fixed income market may bring in 2023.
Click here to see the Globe Investor earnings and economic news calendar.
More Globe Investor coverage
For more Globe Investor stories, follow us on Twitter @globeinvestor
Compiled by Globe Investor Staff
Rob Carrick