Frozen ice is pushed up on shore on Ghost Lake near Cochrane, Alta., in January, 2019.Todd Korol/The Globe and Mail
Melting ice roads threaten to cut off remote communities. Toxic algal blooms are likely to spread. And games of winter shinny could disappear within a generation.
The world’s lake ice is rapidly shrinking as global temperatures climb, with potential to upend everything from seasonal transportation links and recreation to the ecological health of tens of thousands of inland waters, scientists said on Monday.
Climate change could see tens of thousands of lakes across scores of countries in the Northern Hemisphere lose annual winter ice cover under current warming trends, a study published in the journal Nature Climate Change has found.
Even if the world’s industrialized countries limit warming to levels agreed to in the Paris climate accord, the big thaw is likely to force hundreds of millions of people to travel farther to reach lakes that freeze each winter.
York University biologist Sapna Sharma led an international team of researchers that predicts about 35,300 lakes stand to lose their annual winter ice cover should worldwide temperatures increase by 2 degrees Celsius above preindustrial levels.
People skate and play hockey on frozen Lake Ontario at sunset in Kingston, Ont., in January, 2019.Lars Hagberg/The Canadian Press
That’s up from 14,800 lakes that currently experience intermittent ice cover and could jump as high as 230,400 under the most extreme warming scenarios. The retreat has major implications for anywhere from 394 million to 656 million people in more than 50 countries and shows that impacts from climate change are not a distant threat, said Dr. Sharma, an expert in environmental stressors on lakes and the study’s lead author.
Some regions in the northern United States, Sweden, Norway and Canada are already seeing change. “We’re already experiencing these changes,” she said in an interview.
"Lake Superior is no longer freezing every winter, and we’re sort of getting these examples – these iconic lakes are beginning not to freeze every year.”
To assess the threat of ice loss, Dr. Sharma and her colleagues built a model using records for more than 500 lakes across the Northern Hemisphere going back to 875 AD. That included 346 lakes in North America, 136 lakes in Europe and 32 lakes in Asia.
They found that mean annual air temperature was the most important factor for explaining ice cover, although lake depth, elevation and shoreline complexity also played a role.
Lea Parker fishes for trout with Tressa Pelletier, centre, and Anita Parker on frozen Spray Lake near Canmore, Alta., in January, 2019.Todd Korol/The Globe and Mail
The model correctly predicted a lake’s susceptibility to loss of winter ice cover 95 per cent of the time and was applied to a wider database of 1.4 million lakes to determine which ones would maintain annual ice cover, assuming steadily rising global temperatures.
They found that 57,600, or 4.6 per cent, of ice-covered lakes in the Northern Hemisphere could see intermittent winter ice cover under 3 degrees of warming.
That number falls to 35,300 if worldwide temperature increases are limited to 2 degrees above preindustrial levels, as set out in the Paris climate accord.
Conversely, the number of lakes that experience intermittent ice could jump to 215,600 with little to no action to avert the worst effects of climate change.
The numbers have big implications for water quality and quantity.
Years of reduced ice cover tend to coincide with warmer water temperatures and lower oxygen concentrations that can kill fish and increase the prevalence of toxic algal blooms.
Dr. Sharma said the results are likely conservative, partly because they’re based on a subset of data; there are 117 million lakes globally, and more than 50 million of those freeze, she said.
The temperature data also do not reflect the fact that northern regions are warming more quickly than global averages, meaning those regions could lose ice cover at a faster clip.
"It’s a really big problem for us culturally, to think about how we’re going to adapt to this potential change and what does that mean for us as a culture, and our sense of winter identity that we have,” she said.
Editor’s note: (Jan. 29, 2018) The number of lakes that freeze globally has been corrected to more than 50 million instead of 15 million.
Retreating ice cover
Climate change means thousands more lakes
across scores of countries in the Northern Hemi-
sphere will lose annual winter ice cover under
current warming trends, a study published in
the journal Nature Climate Change has found.
Current and future Northern Hemisphere
regions where lakes could experience intermit-
tent winter ice cover with climate warming
KEY
+2.0 °C
+4.5 °C
Intermittent
winter ice: current
+8.0 °C
+3.2 °C
Annual winter ice
Estimated number of lakes, countries
and people affected by current and
projected lake ice loss
Number of lakes
300 thousand
200
100
0
6
8
0
2
4
Temperature increase (°C)
Number of countries
50
30
10
0
6
8
0
2
4
Temperature increase (°C)
Number of people
800 million
600
400
200
0
6
8
0
2
4
Temperature increase (°C)
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL
SOURCE: nature climate change, sharma et al
Retreating ice cover
Climate change means thousands more lakes across
scores of countries in the Northern Hemisphere will lose
annual winter ice cover under current warming trends, a
study published in the journal Nature Climate Change has
found.
Current and future Northern Hemisphere regions where
lakes could experience intermittent winter ice cover
with climate warming
KEY
Annual
winter ice
+2.0 °C
+4.5 °C
Intermittent
winter ice: current
+8.0 °C
+3.2 °C
Estimated number of lakes, countries and people
affected by current and projected lake ice loss
Number of lakes
300 thousand
200
100
0
6
8
0
2
4
Temperature increase (°C)
Number of countries
50
30
10
0
6
8
0
2
4
Temperature increase (°C)
Number of people
800 million
600
400
200
0
6
8
0
2
4
Temperature increase (°C)
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL
SOURCE: nature climate change, sharma et al
Retreating ice cover
Climate change means thousands more lakes across scores of countries in the
Northern Hemisphere will lose annual winter ice cover under current warming
trends, a study published in the journal Nature Climate Change has found.
KEY
Annual
winter ice
Intermittent
winter ice: current
+2.0 °C
+4.5 °C
+3.2 °C
+8.0 °C
Current and future
Northern Hemisphere
regions where lakes
could experience inter-
mittent winter ice
cover with climate
warming
Estimated number of lakes, countries and people affected
by current and projected lake ice loss
Number of lakes
Number of countries
Number of people
800 million
300 thousand
50
600
200
30
400
100
200
10
0
0
0
6
8
0
2
4
6
8
0
2
4
6
8
0
2
4
Temperature increase (°C)
Temperature increase (°C)
Temperature increase (°C)
JOHN SOPINSKI/THE GLOBE AND MAIL, SOURCE: nature climate change, sharma et al