Skip to main content

Elon Musk speaks during the Satellite 2020, at the Washington Convention Center, in Washington, on April 11.BRENDAN SMIALOWSKI/AFP/Getty Images

Elon Musk on Friday put his $44-billion deal for Twitter Inc TWTR-N temporarily on hold, sending the social media company’s shares some 20 per cent lower in pre-market trading and on the Frankfurt stock exchange.

Below are analysts’ reactions to the announcement.

Daniel Morgan, portfolio manager, Synovus Trust, Atlanta

“My question would be if there’s more behind it than just concerns around the number of bot accounts or fake accounts. I know that’s been an issue that’s come out on previous quarterly calls with Twitter. I’m just kind of scratching my head on why that all of a sudden has become such a major issue for him and something he’s using to hold up his $44-billion acquisition.”

“Is there some other issue out there with regards to financing? I know he had a large pool of investors including Larry Ellison at Oracle who were willing to pitch in on the acquisition.”

“Maybe he thinks he can get it at a lower price. The stock is drifting lower. Why all of a sudden has this popped up on the radar screen when he’s known about it for a long time.”

Art Hogan, chief market strategist at National Securities, New York (He disclosed that a family member owns Tesla shares)

“It’s a conundrum because when you step back and look at the stock action of Twitter since it received the initial offer from Musk, it never priced in more than a 30-40 per cent chance of this actually getting completed.”

“There’s been a lot of contemplation that it might not come to bear here. Now Musk’s tweets are stirring up the pot and causing even more confusion. That’s why we’re seeing the stock reaction we’re seeing today. How do we even know what temporarily on hold means.”

“Saying it’s temporarily on hold is not standard operating procedure when you’ve made a tender offer for a company. It’s confusing and also nonsensical. It just doesn’t hold up.”

“Elon Musk, who has secured financing for the tender offer he’s already made, will likely be legally bound to either complete this or pay the breakup fee, which is no small thing.”

“It shouldn’t affect Tesla shareholders. From the beginning of his initial offering and up until now he’s had to pledge less of the Tesla shares as collateral for the financing that he’s doing. So the impact on Tesla has diminished over time, but there still is some. If he doesn’t have to pledge some of the shares, investors of Tesla may be looking at it and saying, okay, he’s not going to be a forced seller to get this deal done.”

Stephane Ekolo, global equity strategist, Tradition, London

“I think that the Twitter story stays a Twitter story without an impact to the broader market. After all, this is just an M&A issue”

Neil Wilson, chief market analyst,, London

“Just always felt like deal was suspect and now get sense it won’t happen and maybe was never going to.”

“I think (short-seller) Hindenburg hit nail on head. Can renegotiate lower price or walks away having off-loaded lots of Tesla.”

Danni Hewson, analyst, AJ Bell, Huddersfield, U.K.

“There were lot of investors thinking that the fact that Musk could come in and was offering a decent amount per share was providing something of a safety net at a time when tech shares are falling. The fact that there isn’t anyone else to step in does suggest that if this deal doesn’t happen, Twitter is going to have to lick its wounds and that’s going to take some time.

“Investors just don’t know quite what this man (Elon Musk) is going to do next. He’s a total maverick. Which makes him either incredibly fantastic or a total liability, depending on which way you look.”

Susannah Streeter, analyst, Hargreaves Lansdown, Bristol, U.K.

“Musk’s Twitter takeover was always destined to be a bumpy ride, and now it risks hitting the skids over the number of fake accounts on the platform.

“There will also be questions raised over whether fake accounts are the real reason behind this delaying tactic, given that promoting free speech rather than focusing on wealth creation appeared to be his primary motivation for the takeover.

“The $44-billion price tag is huge, and it may be a strategy to row back on the amount he is prepared to pay to acquire the platform.”

Emmanuel Cau, head of equity strategy, Barclays, London

“This adds a bit of uncertainty to the tech sector, but I think this is very company specific, I don’t see for instance any impact on European stocks.

“It keeps the pressure on the tech sector though, but my feeling is that there’s limited read-across impact to be expected. Of course, it doesn’t contribute to boost optimism for the sector.”

Michael Hewson, chief markets analyst, CMC Markets, London

“Obviously, the markets are reacting as if he is going to pull out of the deal, otherwise why are Twitter shares down 20 per cent. So maybe he’s (Elon Musk) paving the ground for pulling out of the deal.

“But the timing is curious given the lengths he’d gone to secure financing for the deal. So, maybe some share holders in SpaceX and Tesla said they want his attention on his primary concerns there. This is straight out of the Musk play book, keeping shareholders on their toes.”

Neil Campling, head of TMT Research, Mirabaud, London

“Laughable. We’d always said he may cut or run or change his tune at the 11th hour and 59 minutes and 59 seconds on the clock. It is farcical.

“He has never had the full funding – we know that from his constant attempts to get financial support – but he also held all the cards. And the Twitter board have been held hostage and only have themselves to blame for this mess. No other buyer will emerge – if he decides he is still interested he can ‘name his price’ … and it won’t be higher!

“They (the board) should have seen this coming. There was a specific performance clause in the merger agreement (section 9.9), which gave Twitter the right to ‘consummate the closing (of the deal)’ but only if he had the financing … which he doesn’t.”

Be smart with your money. Get the latest investing insights delivered right to your inbox three times a week, with the Globe Investor newsletter. Sign up today.